Film Review: Captain From Castile (1947)

Release Date: December 25th, 1947
Directed by: Henry King
Written by: Lamar Trotti
Based on: Captain From Castile by Samuel Shellabarger
Music by: Alfred Newman
Cast: Tyrone Power, Jean Peters, Cesar Romero

Twentieth Century Fox, 141 Minutes


I have Captain From Castile listed as a swashbuckling film. The main reason, is because it stars swashbuckling bad ass Tyrone Power. Also, it features lots of swords and people traveling by ship. It is a picture on the verge of swashbuckling greatness but falls short and never really gives you what you’re looking for in that regard.

That doesn’t mean it is a bad film. It is actually a good historical adventure.

The story sees Power’s Pedro de Vargas help an Aztec slave escape his cruel master. He finds himself in trouble and must flee the Inquisition. He later rescues Jean Peter’s Catana Perez. Then he meets an adventurer and they are then swept away to the New World, Mexico to be exact. The film then revolves around the invasion of Mexico by Cortez.

It is a fairly long movie at 141 minutes but it probably could’ve been edited down significantly. There are a lot of sections of the film that drag on too long or where it seems like not enough is happening. The better sequences make up for that though,

Tyrone Power is typical Tyrone Power. Although, he has less to do, not being able to fence his way through baddies and all. It also stars the always enjoyable Cesar Romero and introduces us to the talents of Jean Peters.

The film was directed by the accomplished Henry King, known for Twelve O’Clock High The Snows of KilimanjaroThe Song of BernadetteCarouselLove is a Many-Splendored ThingThe Gunfighter and Jesse James – just to name some of his dozens of movies.

The trailers for the film are in black and white but the movie itself is actually in vibrant Technicolor. The visuals are mesmerizing and the film has a certain feeling of realism, as it was filmed on location in Mexico – utilizing authentic active volcanoes and shooting around real lava beds. The volcanic ash actually created issues on set but the film still turned out to be visually stunning. The filmmakers were ambitious but accomplished what they set out to do from a visual perspective.

The biggest negative of the film is how it ends. It doesn’t really have a proper conclusion, it just sort of stops in what feels like the middle of the story. Almost as if this was the first part of a trilogy that was never completed. The picture only covers the first half of the novel it is based on. This issue, mixed with how long it was and how some scenes could have been cut or edited down, makes the movie feel like a long pilot for a television show that was never picked up and left dangling story-wise.

I do like the film, it just needed more refinement from a narrative standpoint. Tyrone Power never disappoints and he certainly didn’t in Captain From Castile.

Rating: 7.5/10

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s